Access to a court
A protected claim must have a practical and effective route to a court. Disproportionate procedural barriers or costs may be problematic; several levels of appeal are not always required.
We assess potential breaches of Article 6 ECHR and other Convention rights, from the final domestic decision to a possible application in Strasbourg.
An unfavourable judgment is not enough. The issue is whether a procedural guarantee protected by the Convention was breached.
Fairness means more than being allowed to file an appeal. The Court assesses the proceedings as a whole. Article 6(1) applies to the determination of civil rights and obligations and criminal charges; not every administrative case falls within its scope.
We examine specific defects in the proceedings and their significance for overall fairness, not merely the result.
A protected claim must have a practical and effective route to a court. Disproportionate procedural barriers or costs may be problematic; several levels of appeal are not always required.
Judicial independence, a tribunal established by law and objective and subjective impartiality matter. An adverse ruling is not itself proof of bias.
Parties must normally have access to relevant submissions and evidence and an opportunity to comment, including on material from a public authority.
Each party must have a reasonable opportunity to put its case and evidence without substantial disadvantage compared with the other side.
Courts must address decisive arguments and provide adequate reasons. Article 6 does not require every piece of evidence to be admitted or every submission answered.
Public proceedings and pronouncement of judgment are important safeguards, subject to justified exceptions. A hearing is not mandatory in every case.
Delay is assessed in context, including complexity, party conduct, authorities' conduct and the importance of the matter.
Protection may be ineffective if a binding judgment remains unenforced, depending on the nature of the obligation and State responsibility.
Article 6(2)–(3) includes the presumption of innocence, information on charges, adequate defence preparation, legal assistance, examination of witnesses and interpretation.
The Court is not a 'fourth-instance' appeal court. A mere allegation that national law or evidence was assessed incorrectly does not usually establish a Convention violation.
Even a plausible Article 6 complaint must satisfy Articles 34 and 35 of the Convention.
A relevant Convention right must apply and arguably have been breached.
Available and effective domestic remedies must generally be exhausted, with complaints raised in substance.
The deadline generally follows the relevant final domestic decision; its precise starting point depends on the case.
The applicant must generally be personally affected by the alleged violation.
Serious risks in removal, extradition or detention conditions.
Disproportionate public interference, including some immigration cases.
Freedom of expression and non-discrimination in the enjoyment of Convention rights.
Additional Protocols have not been ratified uniformly. Their applicability must be checked for the State concerned.
Identify the State, last decision, notification date and procedural history.
Assess Article 6 and other rights, admissibility and the agreed fee.
Once instructed, prepare the form and annexes in time and in compliance with the Rules.
No. Strasbourg is not a general appeal court; it reviews Convention violations, not ordinary errors of domestic law.
Not always. Immigration, residence and expulsion cases generally fall outside its civil limb, though other rights may apply.
Generally four months from the relevant final domestic decision, subject to case-specific rules.
Generally not. It may find a breach and award just satisfaction under Article 41.
Many cases proceed in writing, and a Strasbourg hearing is not automatic.
Tell us the State, case type, final decision date and suspected violation. Initial triage is free and is not a full file review. Enquiries do not create a retainer or stop deadlines.